Finding a Suitable (Open Access) Journal: Criteria and Tools

The criteria for finding a suitable journal (or other publication venue) include:

  • Subject suitability
  • Position in rankings
  • Type of quality assurance,
  • Reputation of the journal and of those involved in the publication process (e.g. editorial team, peer reviewers, authors)
  • Transparency regarding working practices (e.g. regarding the individuals and institutions involved, and the nature and duration of the various stages in the publication process)
  • Open Access parameters (e.g. transfer of rights, usage licences, compatibility with the requirements of funding bodies)
  • The level of any publication charges.

Infographic: Criteria for a Suitable Journal to Publish

 

The following tools can help you choose:

 

You can find further tips on how to choose here:

  • The Academic Career Kit “Publish your Paper” offered by EconBiz shows you how to find the right journal in five steps.
  • The Open policy finder gives you an overview of the policies of many journal publishers regarding parallel publication in repositories etc. The database contains guidelines on the self-archiving of journals that include information about permitted versions and publishing restrictions.
  • Tips for Finding a suitable journal for a publication on the website Editage Insights.
  • This guide from SPARC, PLOS and the Open Access Scholarly Publishing Association (OASPA) helps you to assess for yourself how open a journal is.

Tip

Predatory journals are not always easy to recognise because the providers go to a lot of trouble to make their journals seem reputable. Sometimes entire editorial boards are filled with false names or well-known researchers are listed as editors without their knowledge on professional-looking websites. You should therefore consult our Checklist for identifying predatory journals when selecting a journal.