Open Science versus Responsible Research & Innovation (RRI)
The concept of Responsible Research and Innovation (RRI) – broadly, research and innovation processes that take responsibility for their effects on society and the environment – was introduced by the European Commission around 2011. In Horizon 2020 (2014–2020), RRI was both a cross-cutting issue and the focus of a dedicated programme, “Science with and for Society” (SwafS). It describes an approach to tackling societal challenges such as global food security. RRI builds on older traditions that aim to bring science and society closer together, such as technology assessment and research on the ethical, legal and social aspects (ELSA) of new technologies. In the current programme, Horizon Europe, RRI no longer has a dedicated funding line, but its core ideas continue in requirements on ethics, gender equality, public engagement and Open Science.
RRI and Open Science share the fundamental values of openness, inclusion and democracy, and Open Access is one of RRI’s core elements; Open Science is therefore often seen as part of the broader RRI agenda. However, RRI is defined more broadly: topics such as ethics, gender equality, public engagement and science education also play an important role. The two also differ in what motivates them. RRI is driven by normative questions – which research is desirable for society, and who should have a say? – and focuses on a responsible process that includes all relevant stakeholders from science, politics, industry and civil society in shaping the goals and methods of research. Open Science takes a more pragmatic approach: it aims to make scientific results, data and methods accessible and to make research more transparent, efficient and reusable, for example through digital infrastructures, FAIR data and Open Peer Review.
Furthermore, an RRI process is anticipatory and reflexive, meaning that researchers are expected to anticipate potential (negative) consequences and to continuously reflect on the impacts of their actions. Other important features of an RRI process include responsiveness and adaptability. These allow researchers to respond to insights gained during the process and adjust their actions accordingly. Open Science, especially in the area of citizen science, can draw on the participatory approaches developed within RRI.